In the school where I now work the students are not allowed to fail. This is not just an aspiration; this is school policy. Not only that, but every student in the bilingual programme is expected to get the equivalent of a high B or A in every subject. Our academic department has decided this. The school believes that if a student isn’t doing well then it is the teacher’s fault and it is up to the teacher to remedy the situation. The implication being that you either just give them a high mark or keep on testing the students until they get it themselves. Most teachers just wind up rewarding marks for no effort. This is because it would be impossible for some of these students to achieve this mark. This is not meant as a slight to them. Where in the world do all the students in a school get top marks all the time?
This way of doing things probably all sounds completely crazy to anyone outside the Thai teaching profession, but this is common practice here. If you don’t like it your choice is to either move to one of the few schools where it doesn’t happen or just put up with it. If we complain to Thai colleagues the usual response is to claim that we just don’t understand Thai culture and we should stop worrying about it so much. If we complain to the management about it the usual response is silence.
I quit teaching full-time a few years back because I felt like a bit of a fraud in front of the students. I didn’t have any proper teaching credentials so what right have I to be teaching them anything? In order to rectify this I spent a lot of money and a lot of time studying for a Post Graduate Certificate in Education while teaching voluntarily in a Thai village school. Four years later with my bona fide credentials in pedagogy I returned to full-time teaching. Yet, here I am a couple of years later feeling again like a fraud.
I spend a lot of my time trying to convince students that studying and learning is important. I try to tell them that exams are important. Yet, all they have to do is look at their classmates how don’t do any work and still come out with high marks. Why should anyone make the effort? The usual way I deal with this is by telling myself that it is the knowledge that is important and not the exam marks, but sometimes it is hard not to feel like a clown. I ask myself the question. If I was a student in my school would I study? The honest answer is no. Why work for something that is going to be given to you anyway.
1 August 2009
25 July 2009
The joys of teaching in Thailand
Spending time around ESL teachers in Thailand might make an outsider think that we really are a lot of whiners. It is understandable why some people wonder why we would put up with the job if things are so bad. If you read the web-forums, devoted to those of us who teach English here, you will see post after post of complaints about the state of the education system in Thailand and the amount of obstacles that are put in the way of those wanting to do the job. It is reasonable to ask why we would put up with it? It’s not like the pay is up to much. What keeps people doing a job which seems to cause them so much stress?
Well, the truth is that despite all our complaints things aren’t really that bad. Teaching has rewards that just aren’t available in other professions. School administration can try and interfere with a lot of things, but once the lesson starts we have a lot of autonomy. The classroom can be like our stage and for the next fifty minutes, to an hour, we have a captive audience. These members of our audience are not passive participants though; not one bit. We have to battle for their attention. If we get it right we can leave the class feeling high as a kite; if we get it wrong we can feel down in the dumps. The highs more than make up for the lows. Occasionally you get a great day, all your classes go well, and you almost skip home from school convinced that you are the best teacher ever.
Another reward of teaching are the students themselves. When I started in the profession my anxiety about what they should or shouldn’t be doing took away from my appreciation of the students as individuals. I am now much more relaxed around them and have found that they can be great fun. They can make me laugh and make me think. I can see how their aspirations are similar to what mine had been at their age. Their enthusiasm makes me feel like a teenager again; it is easy to believe those who claim that teaching young people keeps you young. It can sometimes feel like a real privilege to know them at this special time in their lives.
Teachers can really make a difference to student’s lives. This goes way beyond the lessons that are being taught at the time. I remember all my teachers and they all affected my life in different ways. The impact of teaching students can have an impact way after that teacher has died.
There are also lots of other perks to the profession which keep us in the job. For one thing; it is hardly hard labour. Despite the occasional annoyances I still get days when I think; ‘wow. I can’t believed that I’m being paid for this’. I don’t have a boss on my case all the time, and most of the jobs associated with the job are reasonable.
Teaching in Thailand is not always easy, but it certainly has its good points. We wouldn’t do it otherwise.
Well, the truth is that despite all our complaints things aren’t really that bad. Teaching has rewards that just aren’t available in other professions. School administration can try and interfere with a lot of things, but once the lesson starts we have a lot of autonomy. The classroom can be like our stage and for the next fifty minutes, to an hour, we have a captive audience. These members of our audience are not passive participants though; not one bit. We have to battle for their attention. If we get it right we can leave the class feeling high as a kite; if we get it wrong we can feel down in the dumps. The highs more than make up for the lows. Occasionally you get a great day, all your classes go well, and you almost skip home from school convinced that you are the best teacher ever.
Another reward of teaching are the students themselves. When I started in the profession my anxiety about what they should or shouldn’t be doing took away from my appreciation of the students as individuals. I am now much more relaxed around them and have found that they can be great fun. They can make me laugh and make me think. I can see how their aspirations are similar to what mine had been at their age. Their enthusiasm makes me feel like a teenager again; it is easy to believe those who claim that teaching young people keeps you young. It can sometimes feel like a real privilege to know them at this special time in their lives.
Teachers can really make a difference to student’s lives. This goes way beyond the lessons that are being taught at the time. I remember all my teachers and they all affected my life in different ways. The impact of teaching students can have an impact way after that teacher has died.
There are also lots of other perks to the profession which keep us in the job. For one thing; it is hardly hard labour. Despite the occasional annoyances I still get days when I think; ‘wow. I can’t believed that I’m being paid for this’. I don’t have a boss on my case all the time, and most of the jobs associated with the job are reasonable.
Teaching in Thailand is not always easy, but it certainly has its good points. We wouldn’t do it otherwise.
21 July 2009
Dealing with disruptive students
Dealing with disruptive students can be difficult. If you fail to do it though, these little devils can make your life hell. I have met more than a few colleagues who have experienced sleepless nights because of a class where they felt like they lost control. I personally have walked out of a classroom determined never to teach again. It can take a lot of inner-strength to face students once more after you have had a bad experience with them.
It is easy to just blame the teacher for not having the skill to keep students in check. This definitely seems to be the attitude in Thailand with teachers afraid to admit they are having problems in case it reflects badly on them. This is a real shame because support and exchange of ideas could work wonders to bring these classes back under control. Instead there seems to be classrooms where good students can’t learn because of disruptive students and teachers hide the fact so as not to rock the boat,
I know for a fact that it is not always the teacher’s fault, because I was once one of these disruptive students. I did not want to be in school and even if one of those wonderful teachers like the ones you see in movies (I’m thinking Dead Poets Society here) walked into the room then there would be no way that I wanted to listen. Always blaming the teacher is treating the student like a purely passive variable in the equation; I don’t believe this is the case.
It is not always the disruptive student’s fault either. Why should they be expected to sit through boring classes with teachers who don’t seem to care enough about them to keep them interested? I wouldn’t put up with that either.
The truth is that the problem is caused by a mixture of unique factors and no one answer fits all cases. Sometimes students are disruptive because they don’t want to be in school or because they have serious traumatic event occurring in their life. Other times they are disruptive because the lesson is boring, or that they are tired, or because a teacher told them off for not doing their homework.
It does become easier to control classes as experience in teaching grows. I do believe though, that more should be done to bring the problem out into the open and not to create a blame culture. This problem can drive good teachers out of the profession, and create a learning environment which fails students.
It is easy to just blame the teacher for not having the skill to keep students in check. This definitely seems to be the attitude in Thailand with teachers afraid to admit they are having problems in case it reflects badly on them. This is a real shame because support and exchange of ideas could work wonders to bring these classes back under control. Instead there seems to be classrooms where good students can’t learn because of disruptive students and teachers hide the fact so as not to rock the boat,
I know for a fact that it is not always the teacher’s fault, because I was once one of these disruptive students. I did not want to be in school and even if one of those wonderful teachers like the ones you see in movies (I’m thinking Dead Poets Society here) walked into the room then there would be no way that I wanted to listen. Always blaming the teacher is treating the student like a purely passive variable in the equation; I don’t believe this is the case.
It is not always the disruptive student’s fault either. Why should they be expected to sit through boring classes with teachers who don’t seem to care enough about them to keep them interested? I wouldn’t put up with that either.
The truth is that the problem is caused by a mixture of unique factors and no one answer fits all cases. Sometimes students are disruptive because they don’t want to be in school or because they have serious traumatic event occurring in their life. Other times they are disruptive because the lesson is boring, or that they are tired, or because a teacher told them off for not doing their homework.
It does become easier to control classes as experience in teaching grows. I do believe though, that more should be done to bring the problem out into the open and not to create a blame culture. This problem can drive good teachers out of the profession, and create a learning environment which fails students.
20 July 2009
Please support my blog
I would be really grateful if people would support my blog by visiting the site below and clicking on my articles.
http://www.associatedcontent.com/user/569636/paul_garrigan.html
http://www.associatedcontent.com/user/569636/paul_garrigan.html
11 July 2009
Best advice for those wanting to teach English in Thailand
I always seem to be meeting people who would love to come and teach here in Thailand. My first response is to dish out warnings about the difficulties that people may face. Many of those interested have already developed Thai fever though and can't be dissuaded - I was the same. I made many mistakes on my path to becoming a legitimate teacher, but I also learnt quite a bit. Here are some of my top tips for making the process as pain-free as possible.
1. Have realistic expectations. Working in Thailand is completely different from coming here on holiday; what was once exotic will soon appear everyday and making a living in a sunny place can be just as difficult as elsewhere.
2. Don't come here in holiday mode. If you come to Thailand with the intention of staying then it is vital that you take the whole thing seriously. It is important to quickly develop a normal routine so that you can meet your work commitments. The partying needs to stop, but this does not mean that you can't still have fun and have all the benefits of living in a tropical paradise.
3. Make sure you appear respectable when around colleagues or students. In Thailand this means not walking around the super-market in your swimming trunks and not falling around drunk in front of your students. It also means not doing anything which would reflect badly on employers.
4. Teaching is a profession and requires a professional attitude. It would be wrong to treat it merely a way to extend your holiday. This attitude will reflect in your work. Teaching is a noble profession and you can have an enormous influence on the lives of students; this influence can be good or bad.
5. Become involved in the ESL community. Listen to the podcasts and read some of the many blogs and online articles devoted to teaching English as a Second language; become knowledgeable about the different teaching methods and stay up to date. Check out the Thai teaching related web forums regularly. This knowledge will be impressive at job interviews and more importantly help you develop as a teacher.
6. Get qualified. It is possible to get work without many qualifications but this is not recommended. For legal work the minimum requirement is usually a degree. Attendance at some type of TEFL course is also usually desired.
7. Gain some experience in front of students. A TEFL course is good for this. If you have never stood in front of a group of learners before then it can be a traumatic experience. It is best that you have as much support in the early days as possible.
8. Don't be tempted to submit dodgy certification. Fake degrees are easy to find in Thailand but the consequences for being caught with these are extreme. It is often easy to spot these fake certificates.
9. Try and have some savings for when the shit hits the fan. Thailand does not have any comfortable social security payments for you to fall back on if things go wrong. Make sure you are not caught with your trousers down. Have at least enough money to make it back to your home country. It is also handy to have a credit card from your home country for emergencies.
10 Don't just take the first job that comes along. Research and think carefully. Does the job have health insurance? Does it pay you for twelve months of the year? Will it guarantee you a work permit and help you with this? What will your employers expect from you?
30 June 2009
First Impressions
I have come to realise that the importance of making a good first impression is not just related to job interviews. It also applies to teaching. What happens during any first lesson I have with a new class can set the tone for months ahead, and the impression created during that first meeting can be extremely difficult to change.
This fact can make teaching very problematic. The chaos that often accompanies the beginning of a new school term means that it can be difficult to always maintain a confident and competent manner. It is vital that the teacher gives this impression from the beginning though. Students are highly skilled at sniffing out weakness in a teacher and don't suffer fools gladly. If the class have decided that they are being baby-sat by a disorganised idiot, it can take a lot to change this opinion.
I remember last year being given a last minute substitution and arriving at a class completely unprepared. I managed to keep the class occupied for the hour, but it was obvious that I was making it up as I went along. I left the class feeling embarrassed by my lackluster performance and feeling relived that at least I wouldn't have to face that particular group again. It turned out thought that I was to inherit this class and it took weeks to change the prevalent attitude of, " her comes Mr confusion". Some of the students continued to see me that way until the end of term.
Now I try and treat these first classes like job interviews.
This fact can make teaching very problematic. The chaos that often accompanies the beginning of a new school term means that it can be difficult to always maintain a confident and competent manner. It is vital that the teacher gives this impression from the beginning though. Students are highly skilled at sniffing out weakness in a teacher and don't suffer fools gladly. If the class have decided that they are being baby-sat by a disorganised idiot, it can take a lot to change this opinion.
I remember last year being given a last minute substitution and arriving at a class completely unprepared. I managed to keep the class occupied for the hour, but it was obvious that I was making it up as I went along. I left the class feeling embarrassed by my lackluster performance and feeling relived that at least I wouldn't have to face that particular group again. It turned out thought that I was to inherit this class and it took weeks to change the prevalent attitude of, " her comes Mr confusion". Some of the students continued to see me that way until the end of term.
Now I try and treat these first classes like job interviews.
24 June 2009
Little slips of paper that make me want to hide
Most mornings in our staffroom there is a little ritual which I have grown to loathe. It involves little pieces of paper no bigger than bus tickets. These harmless looking slips have the power to completely ruin my day, because written on each one is information about any substitution class that I will be expected to cover. On a bad day I could end up with as many as three of these loathsome notes; this means three extra hours of work that I hadn't been expecting and won't be getting payed for.
Unfortunately it is difficult to avoid developing a negative attitude towards the person bringing the bad news. Last year it was the same teacher all the time who gave out the substitution slips, and I developed a Pavlovian response of inwardly groaning every time she approached me. This task is no longer her responsibility, but the response is so hard-wired inside my mind that I still automatically worry if she walks near my desk. This year the Thai teachers take turns with this task so anybody approaching my desk in the morning raises my suspicion.
I don't begrudge covering classes for sick colleagues. I don't even mind covering when people just fancy taking self-awarded bonus holidays - I occasionally wish that I had the courage to do this. Sometimes , though, it is just difficult to not feel disappointed when you come to work expecting to finish at noon but need to stay till four. There aren't many perks working in a Thai school, so the occasional early finish is always appreciated.
At the moment we are in the middle of the cold and flu season; swine flu mania is also in the air. Many teachers are unable to make it to work so the substitutions will likely become even more and more frequent over the coming weeks. It is tempting to just go hide in the toilet until the lady with the substitution slips has finished her rounds.
Unfortunately it is difficult to avoid developing a negative attitude towards the person bringing the bad news. Last year it was the same teacher all the time who gave out the substitution slips, and I developed a Pavlovian response of inwardly groaning every time she approached me. This task is no longer her responsibility, but the response is so hard-wired inside my mind that I still automatically worry if she walks near my desk. This year the Thai teachers take turns with this task so anybody approaching my desk in the morning raises my suspicion.
I don't begrudge covering classes for sick colleagues. I don't even mind covering when people just fancy taking self-awarded bonus holidays - I occasionally wish that I had the courage to do this. Sometimes , though, it is just difficult to not feel disappointed when you come to work expecting to finish at noon but need to stay till four. There aren't many perks working in a Thai school, so the occasional early finish is always appreciated.
At the moment we are in the middle of the cold and flu season; swine flu mania is also in the air. Many teachers are unable to make it to work so the substitutions will likely become even more and more frequent over the coming weeks. It is tempting to just go hide in the toilet until the lady with the substitution slips has finished her rounds.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
-1.jpg)